Skip to content

HIPAA guide

HIPAA sanction policy requirement: 45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(C)

One requirement of the HIPAA Security Rule, explained the way an investigator would read it: the text, what it means for a practice or a vendor, the evidence that proves it, and the published cases where it was missing.

Citation
45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(C)
Standard
Security management process, 164.308(a)(1)(i)
Safeguard
Administrative safeguards
Type
Required

What the rule says

Apply appropriate sanctions against workforce members who fail to comply with the security policies and procedures of the covered entity or business associate.45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(C), as currently in force

In plain English: Decide in advance what happens to staff who break your security and privacy rules, write it down, tell everyone, and then do it consistently when it happens. Keep a record each time.

What it means in practice

  • Covers both Security Rule violations (this specification) and Privacy Rule violations (164.530(e) has a parallel requirement).
  • Describes tiers: an accidental first offense is treated differently from deliberate snooping or selling records.
  • Names who decides and who's told, and applies to everyone including owners and physicians.
  • Is applied and documented when something happens: the sanction log is the evidence.
  • Connects to training: staff sign that they've read it.

What happens when someone peeks. That's the short version of this requirement.Your engineer

What OCR looks for

If an investigation touches this requirement, the data request will ask for some or all of the following.

  • The policy itself, approved and dated.
  • Acknowledgments from workforce members.
  • The sanction log, including incidents where the sanction was a documented warning.
  • Consistency: similar violations treated similarly.

Where entities get caught

OCR's 2026 settlement with a small dental practice found it could produce no written privacy policies, including none for patient access requests or breach notification, which necessarily includes no sanction policy. Corrective action plans routinely require a sanction policy and reporting of workforce violations to OCR within 30 to 60 days.

Snooping cases, where staff viewed records of family, neighbors or celebrities, are the classic test: OCR asks what the policy said and what was done.

How to meet it at a small organization

One page is enough: the rules it enforces, three or four tiers of response from retraining to termination, who decides, how it's recorded, and a statement that it applies to everyone. The log can be a spreadsheet. The hard part is applying it to the long-serving receptionist or the owner's spouse; the rule expects you to.

Under the proposed Security Rule update

The proposal keeps the sanction requirement and would require all policies, including this one, to be in writing and reviewed at least every 12 months. The update was proposed in January 2025 and remains a proposal as of October 2026; see what's changing.

This page explains a federal regulation in plain language. It isn't legal advice, and AccuSights doesn't certify compliance; no one can. For every standard and specification, see the Security Rule, clause by clause.

With AccuSights: The AI Policy Builder drafts a sanction policy from your answers about roles and decision-makers, an in-house CISO reviews it, acknowledgments are tracked per person and the incident log records each application.

Quick questions

Is a HIPAA sanction policy required?
Yes, twice. The Security Rule requires sanctions for violations of security policies, and the Privacy Rule requires sanctions for violations of privacy policies. Most organizations write one policy covering both.
What should a HIPAA sanction policy include?
What conduct it covers, a tiered range of consequences, who investigates and decides, how incidents are documented, and that it applies to all workforce members. Many organizations add examples, such as accessing a record without a work reason.
Do we have to fire someone for a HIPAA violation?
No. Sanctions must be appropriate, which means proportionate to the violation. A documented warning and retraining is a sanction. What OCR looks for is that you have a policy, you applied it, and you can show the record.

Sources

Rules, figures and enforcement examples on this page were checked against these in October 2026. Regulations and prices change, so confirm before you rely on them.

  1. 45 CFR 164.308, administrative safeguards (eCFR)
  2. 45 CFR 164.530, Privacy Rule administrative requirements (eCFR)
  3. HHS press release: Shen Smiles settlement
  4. HIPAA Journal: Shen Smiles pays $140,000 to resolve HIPAA Privacy Rule violations
  5. HHS: resolution agreements and civil money penalties

Written by the AccuSights compliance team and updated October 2026. Figures are quoted from the sources named here and were current when checked. This page is general information, not legal advice.

Next step

Want this requirement met and evidenced?

Every Security Rule standard, with the required or addressable status, the evidence that proves it and a named engineer. One fixed fee.

The regulator has the final say. We help interpret, scope and get you ready; we do not certify.

3-min test